Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures

ginoalni
Players

Posts: 5

Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:12:40 GMT -7

Quote

Post by ginoalni on Jun 3, 2015 9:12:40 GMT -7

Hi there,

So... this is a silly question really, but I want to know how you guys would rule this.

So the ruling on having living beings in a bag of holding is that they would only survive 10 minutes before suffocating.
Now, what I want to know is that, hypothetically, if I had sea water in a bag of holding and I decided to store.. living fish in the bag, would you rule the suffocation rule as longer of shorter, or would you not be able to store liquid in a bag of holding?

Get back to me when ever I can, 'tis is but a silly question.

Thanks
Gino

diskelemental Lich Banned A better world, whether you want it or not. Posts: 781	Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:19:06 GMT -7 Quote Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by diskelemental on Jun 3, 2015 9:19:06 GMT -7 Fish still need oxygen, they just get it from the water. I'd rule the suffocation time is the same.
	<tkul_work> actually working on a pretty interesting study that's a pain in the dick because patients keep dying <Rocshaa> Aww <Rocshaa> Wait... <Kimarah> Fuck, the inconvenience!

Zanos Leadership Council No how did i get here i am not good with computer Posts: 684	Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:30:02 GMT -7 Quote Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by Zanos on Jun 3, 2015 9:30:02 GMT -7 Jun 3, 2015 9:19:06 GMT -7 diskelemental said: Fish still need oxygen, they just get it from the water. I'd rule the suffocation time is the same. yep

ginoalni Players Posts: 5	Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:35:59 GMT -7 Quote Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by ginoalni on Jun 3, 2015 9:35:59 GMT -7 Thanks for answering that. ^_^

Haskalah
GM

Posts: 296

Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:51:07 GMT -7

Quote

Post by Haskalah on Jun 3, 2015 9:51:07 GMT -7

Going for the biology angle, water stores far more oxygen, think the goldfish you can win at a fair. I think the time's finite, but the bag seems to assume you use up the oxygen in the air in 10 minutes. A bag mostly filled with water, biologically speaking, should keep fish for several hours.

www.fishlore.com/fishforum/freshwater-beginners/158393-how-long-can-fish-survive-store-bag.html

Though it's still fair to say (and to keep it simple) that a BoH works specifically as noted with a 10-minute limit.

Last Edit: Jun 3, 2015 9:51:54 GMT -7 by Haskalah

Characters:
Salinar Smith - Human Wizard | Varian Jaskas - Half-Elf Arcanist | Gallade Silverleaf - Human Oracle

diskelemental Lich Banned A better world, whether you want it or not. Posts: 781	Bag of Holding and Aqutic creatures Jun 3, 2015 9:54:20 GMT -7 Quote Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by diskelemental on Jun 3, 2015 9:54:20 GMT -7 Correct Hask, I just really didn't feel like doing the math to figure out exactly how much oxygen would be in the water. Thus the simpler ruling.
	<tkul_work> actually working on a pretty interesting study that's a pain in the dick because patients keep dying <Rocshaa> Aww <Rocshaa> Wait... <Kimarah> Fuck, the inconvenience!

Post by ginoalni on Jun 3, 2015 9:12:40 GMT -7

Post by diskelemental on Jun 3, 2015 9:19:06 GMT -7

Post by Zanos on Jun 3, 2015 9:30:02 GMT -7

Post by ginoalni on Jun 3, 2015 9:35:59 GMT -7

Post by Haskalah on Jun 3, 2015 9:51:07 GMT -7

Post by diskelemental on Jun 3, 2015 9:54:20 GMT -7